Letter to America: VIII - Where Obama leads will Congress follow?
Of Senates and Republics and of Presidents and Popes....
SPQR was the signature of Roman Empire...left everywhere on public buildings. The letters stand for the motto: Senatus Populusque Romanus – the Senate and the Roman People.Over centuries it has given rise to many jokes - my favourite is attributed to Pope John XXIII. When the newly elected Pope was taking possession of St John Lateran he noticed the letters SPQR on the papal coat of arms. He pointed to them; then read aloud ‘RQPS’ to Cardinal Alfredo Ottaviani, a noted Latin scholar and his principal rival in the recent conclave. Ottaviani politely corrected the Holy Father. Pope John shook his head and laughed saying: "Rideo Quia Papa Sum" ("I laugh, because I am the Pope").
Even in his modern Imperial pomp the modern President of the United States of America is some way from claims of the Papacy...but looking-on at the tortured path his rivals for the GOP nomination have chosen to take to their convention...President Obama must at least allow himself a wry smile - for he is yet still President - beset as he is by many troubles.
Not least amongst his many troubles are his troubled relations with Congress. Both houses in their different ways have disappointed Obama’s early ambitions to build a new consensus around his decisive election victory.
It might have been naive on his part but the President although equipped with a clear majority in the House of Representatives and a filibuster proof majority in the Senate believed he could build a legislative consensus around the major reforms to Health Care and Environment upon which he had been elected - rather like Regan managed in 1980-1982.
Perhaps he’d not served long enough in the Senate himself to have the measure of his opponents...or perhaps in dealing with the overhang from the financial collapse in the aftermath of Lehman Brothers he used up what political goodwill he had as a consequence of his election - either way - the moderate Republicans refused to get on board the Obama greyhound and ever since the President has been left playing catch-up on the Hill.
The rapid emergence of the Tea Party movement in response to Obama’s election which quickly had behind it the powerful voice of talk-radio hosts like Limbaugh and those once and future kings of all Media in all times - the Murdoch’s News international and their denizens in Fox News – the Tea Party quickly took hold of an already radicalised Republican grassroots.
This radical right- an unstable coalition of fiscal and social conservatives – has to some extent driven the philosophical agenda in American politics since Regan’s decisive if somewhat unexpected victory in 1980. But its roots lie further back in that glorious if disastrous candidacy of Barry Goldwater in 1964. After Goldwater was buried under the Lyndon Johnson landslide won in the aftermath of JFK’s assassination, the Senator from Arizona became something of a prophet for the right.
Goldwater perfectly fused the elements of fiscal conservatism, anti-communism and evangelical Christianity into a bandwagon that big business (not least tobacco) could put wheels on and the men from Madison Avenue could market like cornflakes...soon it rolled smoothly into the political mainstream flattening the opposition with its simple slogans and easy solutions. In Ronald Regan the cause found its perfect preacher - a salesman who could look the camera in the eye and speak from the heart. Soon, the movement had the entire old Republican establishment on the run. After Gerald Ford went down to Carter in 1976...a closer election in the math of the Electoral College than JFK’s in 1960...the party belonged to Regan...Goldwater’s anointed...
These true believers who believed in Regan – rather like the Tory right believed in Thatcher – never thought of the Bush dynasty as true believers. And it turned out the right were right : they weren’t – twice-over. That double misjudgement brings to mind Lady Bracknell's dictum about losing both parents looking like carelessness.
But to some extent George W. Bush at least talked the talk - in his own syntax challenged way. His daddy had refused to talk or walk his campaign into the small arms fire of the Republican right. Instead George H. Bush talked of letting a thousand flowers bloom and no more taxes...his campaign managers did the necessary ugly business of linking hapless Governor Michael Dukakis to being soft on crime....reprieving rapists and muderers and all...which despite Lloyd Bentsen the Senator from Texas balancing the ticket - Austin and Boston as it was known - Dukakis' humanity went down like poison in the South. In 1992 Governor Clinton wasn't about to make the same mistake deliberately flying back to Askansas to sign a death warrant.
So today's Republicans on the right of their party to some extent feel rather like the liberal Democrats, on the left of theirs, felt in the 1960s: that they were robbed on the President they should have had – in their case Hubert Humphrey in 1960; Bobby Kennedy or Eugene McCarthy in 1968.
The politics of the Vietnam War and the political accidents of 1972 – helped along by Nixon’s surrogates in CREEP (Campaign to Re-elect the President) – gave them their chance in 1972 and they seized it and McGovern led the last glorious charge of Liberal Democrats - like that of the Light Brigade it went down to a devastating defeat from which the Democrats have yet to fully recover...
It’s too early to say whether the GOP are about to make a similar fatal choice... and remember the many seasoned Cassandras who thought Thatcher’s election in 1975 as Conservative leader and Regan’s nomination in 1980 were doomed enterprises. But it turned out that as the book of Ecclesiastes promises – to everything there is a season and a time appointed under heaven....
But the actions of others often make things possible that once seemed impossible. Economics and the politics of economics in the US has turned in the president’s favour...and the electorate fickle in its favours is slowly returning to the President. As spring approaches Obama has a spring in his step. Even his opponents whilst denouncing his politics admit the GOP has a mountain to climb. In most of the vital swing states...Ohio, Florida, and Pennsylvania for example the president is ahead by a margin of over 8 points...despite the fact that there is still a marked lack of economic optimism in those very same states.
So if the good news continues to drop as the gentle rain from heaven above the twice blessed President may be more difficult to stop than seemed possible just a few weeks ago. It may be that his clear majority may be reassembled for him by the GOP choosing a candidate outside the mainstream....Santorum...
Former Senator from Pennsylvania, Rick Santorum might well stop Romney in Michigan. He might well do well on Super Tuesday and take Ohio...whilst Gingrich takes his home state of Georgia and Governor Romney is left to pick up crumbs of comfort where he can. But it seems unlikely that Santorum will win over Romney either in the North East - New York and New Jersey - and the far West - not least Utah and California - that vote in primaries in April and June respectively. All this means that makes a brokered convention ever more likely...with Newt Gingrich playing Banquo and Ron Paul the Kingmaker...it may make for exciting television...but what may make the TV ratings rise may not play so well for the Republican Party in the General Election campaign.
If Rick Santorum has in his resume his record in the Senate as the most conservative of social conservatives he also has another place in electoral record books....he lost his re-election to the Senate by a record margin...the largest ever defeat for an incumbent senator. Even the conservative voters in rural Pennsylvania found Senator Santorum too hard to take...so if Santorum wins the Republican nomination and the wins heart of conservative American he may find it much more difficult to win the presidency - when Independents will decide who wins.
But winning the presidency may not be everything....there is still the prize of congress which the Republicans still look most likely to win outright...
But as yet, even if the Democrats hold all their current house seats and win all the toss-ups they would not make it much more than 202-2o5 seats in the House. and they've several seats they're bound to loose. It's hard to see where they'll get the fifteen they need to take control of the house. And in the Senate they need to win every seat and pick up those in Massachusetts and Connecticut to keep safe hold of their wafer thin majority of 51 to 49.
Neither of these things seems likely.
If and when the Democrats reach their convention if they feel emboldened to talk of taking the Congressional fight to the Republican majority; and, if President Obama feels he can boldly ask in his acceptance speech for more than merely another term but for a mandate on the Hill – then you will know that indeed he feels the wind is at his back.
Landslides are rarely manufactured events...but sometimes they can be predicted by other signs...and it is in the Congress that the seeds of any potential landslide for the President will make themselves known. But if it’s to be a tight election be sure the Super PACS will put their money where the power is – expect the fight for Congress to be where their money goes and where the Republican right makes its stands. If it holds its position, it will be is a good position to sit tight and wait out another four years outside the White House - blocking Obama at every turn.
Someone will awake on the first Wednesday of November laughing that is to be sure. Whoever it is, he will doubtless say, akin to Pope John, "Rideo Quia Praefectus Sum" ("I laugh, because I am the President").
But powerful as any President maybe he is no pope.
The founding fathers of the United States, infused by classical education and romantic notions of the Roman Republic as Ciceronian ideal...self-consciously modelled the institutions of their new Republic on those of Classical Antiquity. And the capitol, the house and the senate limit what any President might do and it is to them that the last laugh is given by the constitution of the United States of America.
And only if the Democrats do better than seems likely by any current measure will they have earned the right to laugh the loudest at the end of this long year of elections....
